Here's a sobering fact: 80% of employees prefer regular check-ins over annual reviews yet most companies still rely on outdated processes that waste dozens of hours per quarter. Performance reviews shouldn't feel like paperwork. They should drive real growth.
Modern AI-powered tools can cut review admin time by 70% while delivering insights that actually predict turnover risks and highlight promotion-ready talent. The best platforms now generate review forms in seconds and surface patterns humans miss entirely.
Whether you're trying to boost engagement, prevent costly turnover or simply track progress without the headache, the right performance review software transforms a dreaded process into a strategic advantage. Let's find your perfect match.
{{banner-3="/banner-page"}}
What is performance review software?
Performance review software is a tool that allows you to do structured employee assessments quickly and easily.
It can be used to automate the employee evaluation process, collect feedback, and analyze performance data. Also, it often has 360-degree feedback that provides unbiased employee performance evaluations.
Employee performance reviews give you insight into:
- Employee's progress
- Work quality
- Productivity levels
- Collaboration and teamwork
- Engagement levels
- Turnover risks
- Training and development needs
Before we go further, click here if you want to learn how to conduct a performance review properly.
Key features of performance review software
Here are the performance management features to look for in an employee performance software:
- Customizable review templates: The tool should come with pre-made, editable templates for self, peer, manager, and 360-degree reviews.
- Automated review cycles: You should be able to schedule recurring or one-time review cycles and send automated notifications to employees.
- Multi-rater feedback (360° reviews): The tool should allow you to collect feedback from multiple sources, such as peers, managers, and direct reports.
- Self-assessments: It should provide templates for self-assessments so that employees can reflect on their development.
- Rating scales and qualitative feedback: It supports different formats, such as numeric scores, Likert scales, and open-ended feedback.
- Competency and goal-based evaluations: You should be able to do employee skills assessment and evaluate performance based on individual or team goals.
- Employee development plans: You should be able to create career growth and performance improvement plans. Here are some examples of employee development plans to inspire you.
- AI-powered insights: Choose a tool with built-in AI that can analyze data and generate actionable insights.
- AI-based trends and predictions: Some tools can spot trends and identify high performers and disengaged employees who are at risk of turnover.
Benefits of using performance review software
Here are the biggest benefits you can expect when you start using employee performance review software:
- Increasing efficiency: Performance review software allows you to automate review cycles and sometimes even the analyses of the performance reports, which can save you a lot of time compared to manual reviews.
- Improving employee development: It gives you insights into employees' strengths and weaknesses and helps align employee goals with your company's objectives. Some tools can even generate custom learning and development plans for you.
- Implementing continuous feedback: It's the easiest way to start meaningful conversations with your employees and implement continuous feedback.
- Getting data-driven insights: Performance review tools use AI and machine learning to analyze large volumes of employee data and spot patterns that you may not notice. They can provide you with actionable tips and predictive insights into employee engagement and performance.
- Reducing bias in evaluations: As we already mentioned, performance review software often comes with 360-degree feedback that allows you to collect insights from multiple perspectives and get more objective feedback.
How we evaluated and chose the best software
When choosing the best employee performance management software, we analyzed reviews from the past year on SaaS platforms like G2, Capterra, and Trustpilot. Here are the key criteria we used for our evaluation:
- Functionality – We focused on performance management tools with a wide range of features (performance reviews, 360-degree feedback, engagement surveys, etc) to save you both time and money so that you don't have to purchase multiple tools separately and figure out how to use them.
- Main purpose – Each tool is created for a particular purpose, such as improving productivity, identifying issues in a timely manner, tracking progress, etc. It's important to define the main goal you want to achieve with performance reviews and choose a tool accordingly.
- Ease of use – Let's face it, not all your employees are tech gurus, especially if they don't work in the IT department. Therefore, you need a user-friendly and intuitive tool that doesn't require months of training before you can use it.
- Value for money – It's essential to find the balance between the features and price. We've included different types of tools, from simple performance management systems for small businesses to complex enterprise-level tools, so that everyone can find the right performance review software that fits their budget.
Top 10 performance review software
Here are the best performance review tools we've chosen for you.
Effy AI
{{banner-2="/banner-page"}}
Effy AI is an AI-first performance review platform built specifically for SMBs that want enterprise-level insights without the complexity. What sets it apart is how AI handles the heavy lifting—from generating review forms in 90 seconds to providing instant, actionable insights that actually drive business outcomes.
With Effy AI, you can launch your first review cycle in under 10 minutes and see immediate results. The platform runs everything from comprehensive 360-degree reviews to quick employee check in software directly in Slack or Teams, meeting employees where they already work.
Strengths:
- AI-powered automation: Effy AI auto-generates role-specific review forms in 90 seconds, drafts feedback with tone controls, and creates summaries from raw responses. Its bias detection flags unfair language while AI calibration ensures consistency across managers, delivering predictive insights for retention and promotion decisions.
- Evidence-based 360 reviews: Effy pulls concrete examples from notes and project data to justify ratings, eliminating subjective reviews. The platform offers customizable templates or can generate perfect ones based on your needs. See 360 feedback examples here.
- Zero learning curve: The platform works instantly without training. Managers give feedback as easily as sending Slack messages, with reviews and nudges happening inside tools teams already use. This in-flow experience means natural adoption without lengthy onboarding or change management processes.
- Strong SMB value: The free plan supports unlimited reviews for up to 5 team members with no time limits. Paid plans deliver 70% reduction in admin time and 20-30% feedback quality improvement, helping HR teams save dozens of hours quarterly.
Limitations:
- Selective integrations: Effy AI focuses on deep Slack and Teams integration rather than broad HRIS connectivity. While this means fewer traditional integrations, SMBs often prefer this streamlined approach over complex enterprise system requirements.
- SMB-optimized features: The platform serves teams up to 500 employees best. Large enterprises with complex matrix structures may need more advanced features, though Effy continuously expands capabilities while maintaining its simplicity-first approach.
Lattice
Lattice is a user-friendly people management system that can be used for the employee review process and broader purposes like HR and payroll. It's popular in tech and financial service companies.
Strengths:
- This platform not only covers all aspects of the performance management process, but it can also be used for HR operations.
- Lattice uses AI to analyze performance data. You can get an alert when an employee's performance drops.
- You can customize performance review templates to fit your company's needs. There are various types of templates, from project-based to annual reviews. It even has 1:1 meeting agenda templates.
Limitations:
- Lattice is on the pricier side, and many features require purchasing add-ons, which may not be accessible for smaller companies with tighter budgets.
- It has a lot of features, which can be overwhelming for smaller teams that may not need such a complex platform.
15Five
If you want to implement quick and simple performance reviews, 15Five might be the tool for you. It's based on the idea that employees shouldn't spend more than 15 minutes per week writing a brief report of their work, and managers should be able to review the structured feedback in less than five minutes, saving everyone's time.
Strengths:
- 15Five focuses on improving relationships between managers and employees and boosting managers' effectiveness as they can analyze reviews in less than five minutes.
- It has employee engagement tools, and it can predict what actions can make the biggest impact on improving engagement.
- Its interface is intuitive and easy to use, even for people who have never used a similar tool before.
Limitations:
- It may take some time to fully implement 15Five's processes, especially if your team has complex needs or specific goals.
- While it's great for providing managerial feedback, it doesn't have many features dedicated to peer-to-peer reviews and 360-degree feedback.
Profit.co
Profit.co is a continuous performance management software mostly used by companies that operate on OKR frameworks. You can use it to create tasks and to-do lists and track employee performance.
Strengths:
- Profit.co uses AI to provide real-time insights into employee performance. It can also create projections based on performance trends and historical data.
- Its performance reviews come with 360-degree feedback, providing you with more holistic evaluations.
- Dashboards are collecting data in real time. You may keep reports updated and respond accordingly.
Limitations:
- New users may find the platform difficult to use as it has many advanced features and extensive customization options.
- While it's a good option for larger companies, small teams may find the platform too complex, and some of the features may not be necessary.
PerformYard
PerformYard is a performance appraisal software. You may use it to review your employees and send props in case they’re doing a good job. It's used in industries like IT, finance, and healthcare.
Strengths:
- PerformYard simplifies the performance review process, making it easier to track feedback and performance on a team level.
- It can be used for different types of reviews, such as project-based reviews, multi-manager reviews, or upward reviews. You can also use it to generate a structured staff meeting agenda.
- Review cycles are flexible, and you can customize them to suit your needs. It depends on whether you prefer quarterly or annual reviews or want to implement continuous feedback.
Limitations:
- The analytics is limited, and the depth and strategic insights aren’t comparable to some other tools.
- It may require some time to properly set up and customize this tool. But once set up, it's user-friendly and easy to use.
AssessTeam
AssessTeam is a performance evaluation software that stands out for its database with over 3,000 KPIs for different industries, from customer service to healthcare.
It can also be used for time tracking.
Strengths:
- AssessTeam goes beyond performance reviews and offers other performance management tools. These include 360-degree reviews, self-assessments, and evaluations based on competency.
- The platform is flexible, and you can customize templates, review cycles, and even KPIs.
- It has a lot of integrations, and it works well with tools like Slack, Google Workspace, and various HRIS systems.
Limitations:
- It can be a bit overwhelming for new users due to a large number of features. It may take some time to set up and configure the system.
- The price may be too high for small businesses and startups.
ClearCompany
ClearCompany is one of the best talent management software solutions that can be used throughout the whole employee lifecycle, from hiring and sourcing to improving employee retention. It has built-in performance management and employee engagement features.
Strengths:
- The tool is intuitive and easy to use, both for collecting feedback and rating employee performance.
- It speeds up and simplifies the performance review cycle by automating some tasks that would take up the time of your HR teams. For example, its AI can draft messages and emails that you want to send to employees and new candidates.
- The platform focuses on continuous development rather than just annual reviews. It comes with a large training library, including courses for various soft and hard skills.
Limitations:
- It may not be as flexible and customizable as some other tools.
- Its performance management report lacks some advanced metrics and insights.
Quantum Workplace
Quantum Workplace is an employee experience software that focuses on creating a healthy company culture and strengthening relationships in your team. It has excellent performance management and engagement features.
Strengths:
- Quantum Workplace focuses on team alignment and development, with features like team surveys and peer recognition.
- It tracks performance throughout the whole employee lifecycle, providing you with AI insights to improve your team's performance.
- It also has plenty of tools for measuring employee engagement and satisfaction, such as pulse surveys and retention radar.
Limitations:
- Its features may be unnecessarily complex for smaller teams or companies without HR professionals who can manage performance reviews.
- The initial setup requires some time, especially for larger companies that might need a lot of customization.
BambooHR performance
BambooHR is a comprehensive enterprise workforce management software that can replace multiple other tools you use daily. You can use it for performance reviews and gathering employee feedback, as well as for things like hiring, onboarding, and time tracking.
Strengths:
- The interface is very intuitive and easy to navigate, which makes this HR software accessible to small companies without dedicated HR teams.
- You can customize performance review templates and the frequency of review cycles.
- Since BambooHR is an all-in-one HR software, you can easily integrate performance management with other HR functions like time tracking and payroll and sync employee data effortlessly.
Limitations:
- Although BambooHR has solid reporting tools, it doesn't have in-depth performance analytics like some dedicated performance management tools.
- BambooHR's performance reviews might be too basic for large companies or those that want to do complex evaluations.
Leapsome
Leapsome is an all-in-one performance and learning platform that uses AI to help you automate your work. It has a performance management system, but it can also be used as employee development software, as you can access their course library or create your own learning content.
Strengths:
- You can create automated workflows to simplify tasks that are repetitive.
- Its review templates are highly customizable, and you can build your own performance review using the drag-and-drop principle.
- It has many integrations, and it works well with Slack, Microsoft Teams, and many HR tools like Workday and Workable.
Limitations:
- For small businesses, pricing is less budget-friendly compared to similar tools. You might need to purchase different modules and add-ons to access all the features you need.
- Creating custom workflows and review cycles may initially require a lot of effort and time.
How to implement performance review software in 6 steps
If this is your first time using performance review software, we've got you covered. Here's a step-by-step guide to help you get started successfully, along with best practices that ensure smooth adoption and meaningful results from day one.
Step 1: Define your goals and KPIs
Start by identifying what you want to achieve with performance reviews and which metrics matter most. Common KPIs include task completion rates, productivity levels, engagement scores, and eNPS. Clear objectives help you choose the right tool and measure success. Without defined goals, you'll struggle to prove ROI or improve your process over time.
Step 2: Create or customize review templates
Most modern tools offer pre-made templates, but customization is key to relevance. Add role-specific competencies, company values, and custom questions that reflect your culture. AI-powered platforms like Effy AI can generate tailored templates in seconds based on your needs. The right template makes reviews more meaningful and actionable for both managers and employees.
Step 3: Train your team effectively
Implementation success depends on user adoption. For complex tools, organize hands-on training sessions and create documentation. User-friendly platforms may only need quick video tutorials or Slack messages. Provide constructive feedback examples to help managers write better reviews. Remember, the less training required, the faster you'll see results and engagement.
Step 4: Launch your first review cycle
Send review forms with clear deadlines and expectations about the process. Use automated reminders to boost completion rates—most tools can send these automatically. Communicate the purpose and benefits to reduce resistance. Consider starting with a smaller pilot group to work out any issues before rolling out company-wide.
Step 5: Analyze and act on results
Quality performance review software provides instant insights and visual reports, eliminating manual analysis. Look for patterns in feedback, identify top performers and those needing support, and spot engagement risks early. AI-powered tools can surface predictive insights about retention and performance trends. Share key findings with leadership and create action plans based on data.
Step 6: Optimize and maintain momentum
Gather feedback about the review process itself from managers and employees. Use these insights to refine templates, adjust frequency, and improve the experience. Most successful companies run reviews quarterly or biannually, with lighter check-ins between cycles. Continuous improvement ensures your performance management process evolves with your organization's needs.
Conclusion
The right performance review software pays for itself through reduced turnover and improved productivity. Companies using AI-powered platforms report 20-30% better feedback quality and managers who actually enjoy giving reviews, so imagine that transformation in your organization.
With tools that can launch in under 10 minutes and require zero training, there's no reason to stick with spreadsheets or outdated systems. Modern platforms turn performance management from a compliance exercise into a competitive advantage.
Ready to transform your performance reviews? Start with a free trial of any tool from this list. Your employees will thank you and your HR team will wonder how they ever managed without it.
{{banner-7="/banner-page"}}
